You are currently viewing What to Look for When Buying a Used Car?

Have you ever stood in the middle of a bustling car dealership, surrounded by a sea of shiny metal, and thought, “What should I really be looking for when buying a used car?” This task often feels like a riddle, as there are so many aspects to keep in mind, ranging from the car’s condition to the paperwork involved.

This blog post, inspired by automotive expert, James May’s insights, simplifies your journey. We discuss critical components like mileage, vehicle history, and pricing. Moreover, we share effective negotiation strategies to secure the best deal.

Ready to learn more? This post also unveils industry secrets and shares successful buyers’ experiences. Let’s plunge into the world of used car buying, equipped with knowledge and confidence.

Why Buy a Used Car?

Purchasing a used car has numerous benefits, including lower cost, slower depreciation, and potentially getting a higher-end model for the price of a new entry-level vehicle. It’s an excellent option for budget-conscious buyers and those looking for a starter car.

1. Set Your Budget Wisely

Before you start browsing, it’s crucial to set a budget, a point emphasized in AAA’s Guide to Car Buying.

Factors to Consider

  • Year of the car: Newer cars may come with advanced features but could be pricier.
  • Make and model: This often impacts the car’s resale value.
  • Mileage: A lower mileage often means the car has less wear and tear.
  • Total cost of ownership: Consider insurance, maintenance, fuel costs, and potential repairs.

What are the benefits of purchasing a Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) car?

Purchasing a Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) car offers the buyer an additional level of quality assurance. Typically, CPO vehicles are less than five years old and have fewer than 75,000 miles. Dealers have generally checked and reconditioned these vehicles, often offering warranties for added peace of mind.

2. Understanding Vehicle History Reports

The important step in buying a used car is to understand its history. A vehicle history report can provide crucial information about past accidents, title information, previous owners, and maintenance records.

Companies like Carfax and AutoCheck offer these reports. However, don’t rely solely on these reports as they may sometimes have errors or be incomplete. Always ask the seller about the car’s history and its current condition.

Importance of Vehicle History Reports

This report provides information on the car’s past, including any accidents, recalls, or service history.

What to Look for in a Vehicle History Report?

Look for signs of consistent maintenance, any red flags like major accidents, or if the car has been marked as a lemon.

What can I learn from a car’s VIN?

The Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) reveals important information about a car, including its title and records. Checking a VIN decoder chart, such as the one from NHTSA, quickly verifies if a used car’s VIN information matches the vehicle title and records.”

3. Inspecting the Exterior and Interior of the Car

When inspecting the car’s exterior and interior, Consumer Reports recommends paying close attention to the paint job, body condition, tires, wheels, upholstery, comfort features, and electronic systems.

Always do your inspection in daylight on a dry day as floodlights can hide body defects. The car should have been stationary for at least an hour prior to your inspection.

Inspecting the Car’s Exterior

Observe the vehicle’s exterior for scratches, dents, and rust. Be mindful of larger damaged areas.

  • Paint Job and Body Condition: Look for uneven paint, signs of rust, and dents that may indicate past accidents. Keep an eye out for any rusty spots or paint chips during your walk around the vehicle. Consider the purchase carefully if there are places where the metal is rusted through.
  • Tires and Wheels: Ensure the tires are in good condition and that the wheels align properly.
  • Assess the alignment of body panels. Uneven panels could imply poor accident repairs (CARFAX).
  • Inspect the Frame: Is the car sitting level on the ground? Are there any parts hanging from the undercarriage? Look inside the trunk and hood for new bolts or warping that could indicate a recent accident.

Inspecting the Interior of the Car

Moving inside the car, check the condition of the seats, controls, and other interior elements.

  • Upholstery and Comfort Features: Look for signs of wear on the seats and make sure all comfort features work properly. If the car smells musty, there may be signs of water damage in the carpet and floor mats.
  • Electronic Systems and Controls: Ensure that the dashboard controls, infotainment system, and other electronics function as they should.

4. Under the Hood Inspection

The engine is the heart of any vehicle. With the car turned off, inspect the engine for fluid leaks, corrosion, and cracked hoses or belts. Check the oil and transmission dipsticks for discoloration — the oil should be light brown, and the transmission fluid should be pink or red.

5. Test the Interior Electronics

Make sure the stereo and other electronic components in the cockpit are working properly. Turn on the air conditioning and heat as well. Check for any defects in the interior features, such as weak air conditioning, blown speakers, or missing pixels in displays.

6. Test Drive

A test drive is essential to feel the car’s performance and handling. For electric vehicles and hybrids, ensure the battery is fully charged for a test drive to gauge its projected range.

What to Pay Attention to During the Test Drive?

Listen for unusual sounds, check the brakes’ response, and notice how the car steers and handles bumps. Use your nose to sniff out any foul odors that could indicate engine damage or leaks.

  • Versatile Test Drive: According to CARFAX, during your test drive, you should take the car through different types of roads and at varying speeds to assess if the transmission shifts smoothly. Also, ensure all of the car’s electronics are functioning properly.
  • Assess the Brakes: During the test drive, apply the brakes multiple times at different speeds to check for any unusual noises or pulling to one side, which could indicate brake issues.
  • Sensory Examination: Leave the stereo system off during the test drive and listen to the car’s sounds. Pay attention to any squeaks, rattles, or peculiar smells that could indicate problems like engine damage, transmission issues, exhaust leaks, or mold due to water leaks.
  • Straight Line Test: Drive straight and check if the car tracks in a straight line. Uneven tracking or a “crab walk” could indicate serious body or suspension damage. Also, inspect all tires for uneven wear or low tread (Kelley Blue Book).

7. Getting a Professional Inspection

If you think you’ve found the used car of your dreams, take it to a trusted mechanic for an inspection a step recommended by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).

A mechanic can determine if the vehicle has any underlying issues or areas that might become an issue in the future. It’s not a free service, but it could save you from buying a lemon.

Related Article: Why is it important to have your vehicle inspected

Are low-mileage used cars always a great deal?

While low mileage can indicate less wear and a longer life, it doesn’t guarantee a great deal. If a car is driven infrequently, the plastic and rubber parts may dry out and become brittle.

Consistent use is better for the drivetrain. A low-mileage vehicle that has been poorly maintained may still require costly repairs and reconditioning. It’s important to consider how the vehicle has been maintained and used, not just the mileage on the odometer.

8. Negotiating the Price

Once you’ve asked all the above questions, and you’re getting serious about buying the car, find out how the seller priced it. Use an online pricing guide, like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds, or check online classifieds for similar cars to make sure you’re getting a fair price. Don’t be afraid to negotiate.

Remember, buying a used car is a significant investment. Take your time, do your research, and don’t rush the process. With the right approach, you can find a used car that serves you well for years to come.

9. Making the Final Decision

Before making the final decision, ensure you’re comfortable with the purchase and that the car fits your lifestyle and budget.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Buying a Used Car

As you embark on your journey to buy a used car, being aware of common pitfalls can save you from future headaches. Here are a few things to be mindful of:

  • Ignoring Vehicle History Reports: As we discussed earlier, the vehicle history report is a vital document that should not be overlooked. It’s an essential tool to identify potential problems.
  • Skipping the Test Drive: It’s crucial to get a feel for the car before buying. A test drive helps identify any unusual sounds, odd vibrations, or performance issues.
  • Not Considering Total Ownership Costs: Don’t get fixated on the sticker price. Remember to account for other costs like insurance, maintenance, and fuel.

Financing Tips for a Used Car

Financing a used car is another aspect to consider carefully. Here are a few tips:

  • Understand Your Credit Score: Your credit score impacts the interest rate on your loan. A higher score generally means a lower rate.
  • Shop Around for the Best Rate: Don’t accept the first offer you get. Consult multiple lenders, including banks, credit unions, and online lenders.
  • Consider Pre-Approval: Getting pre-approved for a loan gives you a better understanding of what you can afford and puts you in a stronger negotiating position.

Explore more on financing: Can I buy a car while on welfare? Get the answers you need to make an informed decision!

Questions to Ask When Buying a Used Car

Navigating the used car market can be a daunting task, but asking the right questions can make the process smoother and more rewarding.

1. Are the Service and Maintenance Records Available?

Always request the service and maintenance records of the car. For example, you could ask if the seller has records of oil changes, tire rotations, brake repairs, and any other major maintenance or repairs that have been done to the car.

These documents provide a clear picture of the car’s health and how well it has been maintained. Regular servicing is a good sign of a well-maintained car. If these records aren’t available, it could be a red flag.

2. What is the Car’s Ownership History?

Understanding the car’s ownership history can give you insights into its reliability. If the car was previously used for ridesharing, it might have more wear and tear than a personal vehicle. Find out if the current owner is the first, and if not, how many people owned it before and for how long. A car with fewer previous owners is generally preferable.

3. Does the Car Have a Clean Title?

Ensure the vehicle has a clean title. Avoid cars with a “salvage title” as they might still have hidden problems. Knowing the status of the title early on can help you decide if the car is worth the extra time and hassle.

4. How was the Price Determined and is it Negotiable?

Inquire about how the seller arrived at the price and if it’s negotiable. Use an online pricing guide, like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds, to ensure you’re getting a fair price. If the price is significantly higher than the average market price, ask the seller to justify the difference.

5. Can I Take the Car for a Test Drive?

Always insist on a test drive. This is particularly key for used cars as it can reveal potential problems a seller might not disclose. Pay attention to how the car handles, brakes, and accelerates. Any unusual noises or vibrations could indicate underlying issues.

6. Can I Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection?

Always get a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic. A pre-purchase inspection is especially important if you’re not familiar with cars or if you’re not sure what to look for. A mechanic can help you identify any potential problems with the car before you buy it. If a seller refuses an inspection, consider it a red flag.

7. Is the Seller an Automotive Enthusiast?

Buying from automotive enthusiasts can be a bonus. They usually take good care of their vehicles and invest in quality parts and repairs. They can usually provide a detailed rundown about the car and its history.

8. Was the Vehicle Garaged?

Find out if the vehicle was garaged. A car kept indoors away from harsh weather conditions should be in better condition than a vehicle left outside against the elements.

9. Where Did the Car Come From?

It’s important to know where a used vehicle came from. Vehicles driven in sunny areas with no rust issues will almost always last longer and have fewer suspension issues than those from northern states where the roads are heavily salted.

10. Was the Car Driven Regularly?

Older vehicles don’t like to sit around. A car driven daily tends to have its issues looked after more regularly than one which sits for weeks and months.

11. Does the Car Have Any Protection Accessories or Upgrades?

Check if the car has any protection accessories or upgrades. This shows the prior owner cared enough to spend money on nice materials and they wanted to make this car a keeper.

12. Has the Vehicle Been in Any Accidents?

Ask if the car was in any accidents, how it was damaged, and how it was fixed. A car that was in an accident but not repaired well might pose problems down the line.

13. Were Quality Parts Installed?

When you have a used vehicle inspected by an experienced independent mechanic, ask them if the prior owner installed quality components or just relied on the cheap stuff.

Remember, buying a used car requires due diligence on your part. Don’t rush the process and make sure to ask all the necessary questions to ensure you’re making a good investment.


While buying a used car can be a complex process, understanding what to look for can make it much more manageable and help you find a reliable vehicle that meets your needs and fits your budget.

Jane personal experience:

Jane, a reader of our blog, successfully used our used car buying guide to her advantage. Despite being a first-time buyer, she managed to secure a 5-year-old sedan for 15% less than the asking price, thanks to the research she did on our blog. Two years later, she still drives the same reliable car, reinforcing the value of thorough research.


Mike personal experience:

Mike, on the other hand, shared his experience of rushing into a used SUV purchase without adequate research. Unfortunately, he ended up with costly transmission repairs just a few weeks later. His story reminds us of the importance of following a comprehensive buying guide like the one we provide on our blog.

Now it’s your turn. Are you ready to navigate your car-buying journey armed with knowledge? Share your thoughts and questions in the comments. If our stories and guides have been helpful, consider sharing them with others who might benefit. Don’t forget to subscribe to our blog for more insights and practical tips. Remember, an informed buyer is a smart buyer!


What is the best place to buy a used car?

There are various options, including dealerships, private sellers, and online platforms. Each has its pros and cons, so choose what suits your needs best.

How old should a used car be when I buy it?

This depends on your budget and needs. Generally, cars that are 3-5 years old offer the best balance between cost and features.

How many miles is too many for a used car?

Generally, a car with over 100,000 miles may require more maintenance. However, a well-maintained car can run smoothly even beyond that.

What are some red flags when buying a used car?

Some red flags include a salvage title, inconsistencies in the vehicle history report, signs of severe damage or rust, and a seller who’s hesitant to have the car inspected.

Is it better to buy from a dealership or a private seller?

Dealerships often offer more protection and options, while private sellers may have lower prices. Consider your priorities before deciding.


  • Naveed Ahmed

    Hello there, I'm Naveed Ahmed, an experienced auto industry blogger with over 5 years of experience. My passion for cars and trucks started at a young age, and I've been writing about them ever since. I strive to provide readers with accurate, up-to-date information that can help them make informed decisions when it comes to buying, selling, or transporting their vehicles. As an expert in the auto industry, I'm always keeping an eye on the latest trends, innovations, and changes in the market. When I'm not writing about cars, you can find me tinkering with my own vehicle or exploring new scenic drives. I'm also a big fan of classic cars and enjoy attending car shows and auctions.

    View all posts